1. USA
  2. New Jersey
  3. Plum Island
  4. Summer Rental

Plum Island Summer Rentals, Cottages & Cabins

Book a Place to Stay in Plum Island for Your Summer Getaway

About Plum Island Summer Rental on Rent By Owner

With 103 summer rentals in or near Plum Island, choosing a suitable rental home for your upcoming summer getaway on Rent By Owner is easy. Whether you are traveling with family, friends, or in a group to Plum Island or areas nearby, RBO has plenty of summer accommodations to choose from, many with top amenities such as private pools, indoor/outdoor pools, hot tubs, WiFi, beach access, nearby parks, luxury bedrooms, bathtubs, and pet-allowed environments.

Looking for a relaxing place to stay in Plum Island for a summer vacation you do not want to forget easily? Rent By Owner summer rental homes are available to provide you with the maximum comfort you deserve. Whether you're needing a unique style condo, luxury resort, villas, bungalow, cozy cabin, RV, or cottage in Plum Island, RBO has got you covered for your next summer holiday.

Show more
Show less

Frequently Asked Questions About Plum Island Luxury Rentals

There are a lot of options in Plum Island. If you plan on staying in the Plum Island area, consider making a reservation for a few nights at one of these properties as these have been rated the top Summer Rentals in Plum Island:

In 2025, RBO offers 103 summer rentals in or around Plum Island. Find unique home rentals for your summer holiday or a weekend getaway with family and friends.
The average price per night for a summer rental in Plum Island is $464. Check the full list of summer accommodations in Plum Island.
There are 103 summer rentals, cabins, cottages and properties that are available to rent. Book for your next trip with Rent By Owner.

Yes, here are some popular summer holiday rentals in Plum Island that have a private or indoor pool:

Check all holiday rentals with a pool in Plum Island on Rent By Owner.