1. USA
  2. New Jersey
  3. Plum Island
  4. Rentals by Owner

Discover Your Perfect Plum Island Rentals by Owner

Plum Island Rentals by Owner

More Top-Rated Rentals by Owner in Plum Island Area

Why Choose Rent By Owner for your Plum Island vacation rental?

What makes our Rentals by Owner special?

image
Verified Listings
Book with confidence knowing every property meets our quality and safety standards.
image
Unbeatable Value
Enjoy competitive pricing with no hidden fees, providing exceptional value for every stay.
image
Diverse Options
From cozy cabins to luxurious villas, find a rental that suits your style and needs.

Popular Areas for Plum Island Rentals by Owner

Where are the best neighborhoods to stay in Plum Island?

Discover the best neighborhoods to stay in on Plum Island, Highlands, New Jersey, USA, and enjoy a memorable coastal retreat. Whether you prefer the tranquil surroundings near the shoreline or the vibrant local communities, these areas provide an ideal setting for your rental by owner experience. With Rent By Owner, you can find trustworthy vacation rentals that offer comfort and convenience, making it easy to explore the charming neighborhoods of Highlands while ensuring a seamless booking process tailored to your needs.

Queens

Located just across the water from Highlands, Queens offers a vibrant urban environment with diverse dining and cultural experiences, making it an ideal area for travelers seeking both convenience and excitement while exploring the region.

View 996+ Rentals in Queens

Sandy Hook

This picturesque destination in Highlands provides tranquil beaches and scenic views, perfect for relaxing seaside getaways and enjoying the natural beauty of the New Jersey coastline.

View 73+ Rentals in Sandy Hook

Brighton Beach

Known for its lively atmosphere and unique cultural vibe, Brighton Beach offers an authentic experience close to the boroughs, making it a popular choice for visitors looking to stay near the coast.

View 97+ Rentals in Brighton Beach

Sheepshead Bay

This neighborhood boasts a serene waterfront setting with easy access to fishing, boating, and seafood dining, offering a peaceful retreat just a short distance from the city’s hustle.

View 111+ Rentals in Sheepshead Bay

South Beach

South Beach is renowned for its scenic shoreline and relaxed community vibe, providing a charming spot for beach lovers wanting to enjoy the coastal scenery nearby.

View 36+ Rentals in South Beach

Manhattan Beach

Offering beautiful sandy shores and a welcoming atmosphere, Manhattan Beach attracts visitors seeking a laid-back coastal escape within easy reach of Brooklyn's attractions.

View 105+ Rentals in Manhattan Beach

Belle Harbor

This quiet yet accessible neighborhood features wide beaches and a friendly community, making it a desirable spot for those looking for a peaceful coastal stay close to the city.

View 54+ Rentals in Belle Harbor

Port Monmouth

Situated along the shore, Port Monmouth offers scenic waterfront views and convenient access to outdoor activities, ideal for travelers aiming to explore the natural surroundings here.

View 56+ Rentals in Port Monmouth

Best Times to Visit Plum Island

When should you plan your Rentals by Owner stay?

Timing your visit to this charming coastal area ensures you experience its beauty at its best, whether you prefer the lively summer months or the quieter off-season, making it ideal for finding the perfect vacation rental by owner through Rent By Owner in Highlands, New Jersey.

Peak Season Highlights

summer
Summer (June to August)

During the summer months, you can enjoy warm weather and ideal conditions for outdoor activities along this coast, making it the perfect time to book a rental by owner on this destination.

Average Temperature Daytime: 75°F to 85°F - Nighttime: 65°F to 70°F
autumn
Fall (September to November)

Early fall offers pleasant temperatures and fewer crowds, providing an excellent opportunity for relaxing stays while experiencing the region’s natural beauty at its peak.

Average Temperature Daytime: 65°F to 75°F - Nighttime: 55°F to 60°F

Off-Season Highlights

image
Winter (December to February)

The winter months tend to be quieter here, giving you a chance to enjoy a peaceful retreat away from the crowds while still benefiting from comfortable accommodations.

Average Temperature Daytime: 40°F to 50°F - Nighttime: 30°F to 40°F
image
Spring (March to May)

In early spring, the area begins to bloom, but fewer visitors mean more availability for your preferred rental by owner options, offering a tranquil experience.

Average Temperature Daytime: 50°F to 60°F - Nighttime: 40°F to 45°F

Weekly Weather Forecast for Plum Island

How to Book Your Plum Island vacation rental

What's our booking process?

Our platform allows you to browse a curated selection of rentals by owner. Once you find the ideal property, you’ll be redirected to a trusted booking partner to complete your reservation securely.

Booking Steps

01

Search Properties

Use our filters to find the right property that fits your needs.
02

Select a Rental

Click on your preferred listing to view details, amenities, and pricing.
03

Book Online

Follow the link to finalize your reservation directly on the partner’s website.

Explore and book the perfect rental in Plum Island

More Top-Rated Rentals by Owner in Plum Island Area

Common Rentals by Owner Amenities

What amenities can you expect?

Our Rentals by Owner are designed to offer all the comforts of home, often with added perks to make your stay unforgettable. Here’s some common amenities to look forward to:

Indoor Features

  • Fully-equipped kitchens with modern appliances
  • Comfortable living areas with flat-screen TVs
  • Free Wi-Fi for staying connected
  • Air conditioning and heating for year-round comfort
  • In-unit washers and dryers for convenience
  • Luxurious bedrooms with premium bedding
  • Spa-like bathrooms with soaking tubs or walk-in showers

Outdoor Amenities

  • Enjoy access to a private or shared outdoor patio or deck, perfect for relaxing or dining al fresco.
  • Take advantage of well-maintained outdoor grilling areas to prepare meals during your stay.
  • Relax in a scenic backyard or garden space that offers a peaceful retreat after a day at the shore.
  • Make use of convenient outdoor parking facilities, ensuring ease of arrival and departure.
  • Find accommodations with direct access to nearby beaches or waterfront areas for easy daily excursions.
  • Utilize outdoor showers or rinsing stations ideal for washing off sand or salt after beach visits.
  • Benefit from outdoor recreational amenities such as picnic tables or fire pits, creating memorable gatherings here in this coastal region.

Top Attractions Around Plum Island

What attractions are nearby?

In this charming coastal area, you can enjoy a variety of outdoor activities such as relaxing on the pristine beaches, exploring scenic nature trails, or engaging in water sports, all conveniently located near your rental by owner in Highlands, New Jersey.

image
image

Family Activities

  • Sea Bright Beach: Relax on this family-friendly beach known for its gentle waves and clean sands, perfect for a day of sun and sand along the region's coastline.
  • Marine Park: Explore scenic walking trails, picnic spots, and open green spaces where you can enjoy outdoor activities with your loved ones in this local park.
  • Highlands Historical Society Museum: Discover the area's rich history through engaging exhibits and interactive displays that are ideal for curious minds and young explorers.
  • Harbor Cruises: Take a family-friendly boat tour from here to enjoy stunning views of the harbor and spot local marine life, making it a memorable experience for all ages.
image

Adult Activities

  • Wildlife Watching Tours: Embark on guided wildlife watching excursions to observe the region's diverse bird species and marine life in their natural habitat.
  • Beach Relaxation and Sunbathing: Spend your days lounging on the pristine sands, soaking up the sun while enjoying the peaceful coastal scenery that surrounds this destination.
  • Kayaking and Paddleboarding: Explore the calm waters and scenic inlets by renting kayaks or paddleboards, offering an active way to experience the area's natural beauty.
  • Fishing Excursions: Join local charters for fishing trips along the coast, where you can try your luck catching a variety of fish native to this region.

Plum Island Travel Tips

How Can You Make the Most of Your Stay?

  • Plan Your Activities Ahead: Take advantage of the scenic surroundings by scheduling outdoor excursions or coastal walks to fully enjoy your visit here.
  • Choose Your Rental Carefully: Opt for a private vacation home that offers the comfort and amenities you need to relax after exploring the area's natural beauty.
  • Check Local Regulations: Familiarize yourself with any regional guidelines or practices to ensure a smooth and enjoyable stay in this destination’s community.
  • Make the Most of the Waterfront: Use the proximity to the water to indulge in peaceful mornings by the shore or sunset views from your rental, enhancing your experience here.

Transportation Options

  • Local Bus Services: You can utilize regional bus routes that connect Highlands with neighboring towns, offering an affordable and convenient way to explore the area without a car.
  • Taxi and Rideshare Options: Taxis and rideshare services are readily available here, providing flexible transportation to your rental and nearby attractions in the region.
  • Private Car Rentals: Renting a car locally allows you to enjoy the scenic drives around this coastal destination at your own pace, ideal for exploring more remote areas.
  • Walking and Biking: The area offers charming walkable streets and bike-friendly paths, making it easy to navigate your surroundings while soaking in the local scenery.

Local Customs Options

  • Respect for Local Maritime Traditions: Visitors often observe the area's longstanding maritime customs, including participating in or observing traditional boating and fishing practices.
  • Environmental Conservation Etiquette: The community places a high value on preserving the natural beauty of the region, encouraging guests to follow responsible practices when exploring beaches and coastal areas.
  • Celebration of Seasonal Festivals: Seasonal events and festivals highlight local culture, offering visitors an authentic experience rooted in regional customs and traditions.
  • Respect for Quiet Coastal Living: The area values tranquility and respectful behavior, especially during quiet hours, to maintain the peaceful atmosphere that attracts many vacationers seeking relaxation.

Frequently Asked Questions About Plum Island Rentals by Owner

1. What are the top vacation rentals in Plum Island?

There are a lot of options in Plum Island. If you plan on staying in the Plum Island area, consider making a reservation for a few nights at one of these properties as these have been rated the Top Vacation Rentals in Plum Island:

2. How many Rentbyowner vacation rentals are available in Plum Island?

Currently, the total number of properties listed by Rent By Owner in 2025 is over 86 in the Plum Island area, and still counting. By aggregating listings from multiple websites, Rent By Owner offers an immense amount of choice of the best RBO properties in Plum Island. 

3. What is the cancellation policy for rental properties on Rent By Owner in this area?

Cancellation policies vary by individual property listing. You should review the specific cancellation terms provided in the booking details or contact the owner directly to understand the restrictions and refund options before confirming your reservation.

4. Are there any house rules or requirements I need to be aware of when booking a rental by owner in this destination?

Yes, each property has its own set of house rules which are outlined in the listing. It’s recommended to read these carefully or reach out to the owner if you have any questions to ensure your stay aligns with their expectations.

5. How do I verify the safety and reliability of a rental property listed by an owner in this region?

Rent By Owner provides detailed property descriptions, reviews from previous guests, and owner contact information. You can also communicate directly with the owner to ask questions about safety measures and amenities to ensure the property meets your standards.

6. What should I know regarding check-in and check-out procedures for rentals by owner in this area?

Check-in and check-out times are specified in each listing. Many owners offer flexible arrangements, but it’s best to confirm these details ahead of time by reviewing the property description or contacting the owner directly.

7. Are pets allowed in rentals by owner in this part of the region, and how do I request pet accommodations?

Pet policies vary among individual listings. To find pet-friendly options, filter your search accordingly or contact the owner directly to inquire about bringing your pets, including any additional fees or restrictions they may have.

More Rentals You May Like Near Plum Island

More Top-Rated Rentals by Owner in Plum Island Area